{"hedges":{"name":"hedges","families":{"may":["may"],"might":["might"],"could":["could"],"suggest":["suggest","suggests","suggested","suggesting"],"indicate":{"pattern":"\\b(?<!as\\s)indicat(?:e|es|ed|ing)\\b(?!\\s+whether)"},"appear":{"pattern":"\\b(?:it\\s+appears?\\s+that|appear(?:s|ed)?\\s+to)\\b"},"seem":["seem","seems","seemed"],"possible":["possible"],"possibly":["possibly"],"perhaps":["perhaps"],"likely":{"pattern":"\\b(?:it\\s+(?:is|seems|was)\\s+(?:un)?likely|(?:is|are|was|were|seems?)\\s+(?:un)?likely\\s+that|(?:un)?likely\\s+to\\s+be|will\\s+likely)\\b"},"tend":["tend","tends","tended"],"generally":["generally"],"largely":["largely"],"mostly":["mostly"],"essentially":["essentially"]},"phrases":{"consistent_with":["consistent with"],"cannot_rule_out":["cannot rule out","can not rule out"],"interpreted_with_caution":["interpreted with caution"],"under_assumptions":["under our identifying assumptions","under the identifying assumptions"]}},"boosters":{"name":"boosters","families":{"significant":["significant","significantly"],"strong":["strong","strongly","stronger","strongest"],"robust":["robust","robustness"],"clear":["clear","clearly"],"demonstrate":["demonstrate","demonstrates","demonstrated","demonstrating"],"show":["show","shows","showed","shown"],"establish":["establish","establishes","established","establishing"],"confirm":["confirm","confirms","confirmed","confirming"],"certainly":["certainly"],"evident":["evident","evidently"],"absolute":["absolute"],"actually":["actually"],"always":["always"],"apparent":["apparent"],"assert":["assert","asserts","asserted","asserting"],"assertion":["assertion","assertions"],"considerable":["considerable"],"consistently":["consistently"],"constantly":["constantly"],"definitely":["definitely"],"determine":["determine","determines","determined","determining"],"dramatically":["dramatically"],"eminently":["eminently"],"emphasise":["emphasise","emphasises","emphasised","emphasising","emphasize","emphasizes","emphasized","emphasizing"],"entirely":["entirely"],"especially":["especially"],"evidence":{"pattern":"\\b(?:strong|compelling|convincing|considerable|substantial|clear|robust|ample)\\s+evidence\\b"},"exceptionally":["exceptionally"],"extensively":["extensively"],"extraordinary":["extraordinary"],"for_the_most_part":["for the most part"],"fully":["fully"],"highlight":["highlight","highlights","highlighted","highlighting"],"highly":["highly"],"hold":["hold","holds","held","holding"],"importantly":["importantly"],"in_effect":["in effect"],"in_fact":["in fact"],"indeed":["indeed"],"know":["know","knows","knew","known","knowing"],"vast_majority":{"pattern":"\\bvast\\s+majority\\b"},"obvious":["obvious"],"of_course":["of course"],"paramount":["paramount"],"particularly":["particularly"],"precisely":["precisely"],"primarily":["primarily"],"prove":["prove","proves","proved","proven","proving"],"reveal":["reveal","reveals","revealed","revealing"],"stress":{"pattern":"\\b(?:we|i)\\s+stress\\b|\\bstress(?:es|ed)?\\s+that\\b"},"substantially":["substantially"],"surely":["surely"],"thrilling":["thrilling"],"to_a_large_extent":["to a large extent"],"truly":["truly"],"underscore":["underscore","underscores","underscored","underscoring"],"undoubtedly":["undoubtedly"],"unquestionably":["unquestionably"],"utmost":["utmost"],"well_within":["well within"],"widely":["widely"]}},"connectives":{"name":"connectives","families":{"sequential":{"pattern":"(?-i:\\b(?:First|Firstly|Second|Secondly|Third|Thirdly|Finally)\\b(?!-))"},"next":{"pattern":"\\bnext\\s*,"},"causal":["therefore","thus","hence","consequently","as a result"],"concession":["although","though","while"],"meanwhile":["meanwhile"],"contrast":["however"],"additive":["moreover","furthermore","in addition","additionally"],"further":{"pattern":"(?-i:\\bFurther\\b\\s*,)"},"focusing":["in particular","specifically"],"exemplifying":{"pattern":"\\bfor (?:example|instance)\\b|\\be\\.g\\."},"contrastive_pair":["in contrast","conversely"],"confirming":["indeed","in fact"],"strong_concession":["nevertheless","nonetheless"],"but_initial":{"pattern":"(?-i:\\bBut\\b)"}},"groups":{"adversative":["contrast","concession","strong_concession","contrastive_pair","but_initial"],"total":["sequential","next","causal","concession","meanwhile","contrast","additive","further","focusing","exemplifying","contrastive_pair","confirming","strong_concession","but_initial"]}},"signposts":{"name":"signposts","items":{"note_that":"\\b(note|notice) that\\b","importantly":"\\b(importantly|crucially|notably)\\b","back_reference":"\\bas (mentioned|noted|discussed|shown|described) (above|earlier|before)\\b","forward_reference":"\\b(as (we (will|shall) see|shown below|discussed below)|to which we (now )?turn|we now turn|(in|see) the next (section|subsection)|following section)\\b","cross_reference":"\\b(see|cf\\.?) section \\d|\\bas (discussed|shown|described|noted|explained|outlined) in section \\d|\\bsection \\d (shows|presents|describes|discusses|provides)\\b","transition":"\\bturning (now )?to\\b|\\bhaving established\\b|\\bwith this in mind\\b","recall":"\\brecall that\\b","summarising":"\\b(to summari[sz]e|in summary)\\b"}},"reporting_verbs":{"name":"reporting_verbs","stances":{"endorsing":["show","shows","showed","shown","demonstrate","demonstrates","demonstrated","establish","establishes","established","confirm","confirms","confirmed","prove","proves","proved","proven","points","pointed"],"neutral":["find","finds","found","estimate","estimates","estimated","report","reports","reported","examine","examines","examined","document","documents","documented","study","studies","studied","analyse","analyses","analysed","analyze","analyzes","analyzed","investigate","investigates","investigated","use","uses","used","consider","considers","considered","provide","provides","provided","propose","proposes","proposed","present","presents","presented","conclude","concludes","concluded","note","notes","noted","observe","observes","observed","state","states","stated","derive","derives","derived","introduce","introduces","introduced","develop","develops","developed","predict","predicts","predicted","compare","compares","compared","emphasise","emphasises","emphasised","emphasize","emphasizes","emphasized","stress","stresses","stressed","highlight","highlights","highlighted"],"distancing":["argue","argues","argued","claim","claims","claimed","suggest","suggests","suggested","posit","posits","posited","contend","contends","contended","maintain","maintains","maintained","insist","insists","insisted","speculate","speculates","speculated","question","questions","questioned"],"assumption":["assume","assumes","assumed","suppose","supposes","conjecture","conjectures","conjectured"]},"extending":["extend","extends","extended","build","builds","built","follow","follows","followed"]},"phrases":{"name":"phrases","roadmap":["organi[sz]ed as follows","proceeds as follows","structured as follows","structure of (this|the) paper","remainder of (this|the) (paper|article)","rest of (this|the) (paper|article)","plan of (this|the) paper","outline[sd]? as follows"],"roadmap_section_refs_min":3,"results_preview":["\\bwe (find|show|document|demonstrate)\\b","\\bwe estimate that\\b","\\bour (results|findings|estimates) (show|suggest|indicate|imply|reveal)\\b"],"gap_language":{"little_research":"\\blittle research\\b","no_study":"\\bno (study|studies|prior study|previous study)\\b","few_studies":"\\bfew studies\\b","less_known":"\\bless is known\\b","overlooked":"\\b(overlooked|neglected|ignored)\\b","remains":"\\bremains? (unexplored|unclear|unresolved|an open question)\\b"},"contribution":"\\bcontribut(e|es|ed|ing|ion|ions)\\b","limitation":"\\blimitations?\\b","policy":"\\b(policy|policies|implications?)\\b","future_research":"\\bfuture (research|work|studies|analysis)\\b|\\bfurther research\\b","conclusion_openers":{"in_summary":"^(in (conclusion|summary)|to summari[sz]e|summing up)","this_paper":"^(this (paper|study|article|chapter)|the present (paper|study)|in this (paper|study|article)|the (paper|study|article) has)","we_our":"^(we|our)\\b"},"abstract_openers":{"we":"^(in this (paper|study|article),?\\s*we|we)\\b","this_paper":"^this (paper|study|article)\\b"},"paper_focused_intro_start":"^(in this (paper|study|article)|this (paper|study|article)|we |our )"},"moves":{"name":"moves","units":{"introduction":{"move1_territory":{"importance":"\\b(?:is (?:a )?(?:central|crucial|important|key) (?:to|for|question|issue|concern)|plays? (?:a|an) (?:key|central|important|crucial) role)\\b","literature":"\\b(?:large|growing|extensive|substantial|vast|long|rich) (?:literature|body of (?:work|research|literature))\\b","attention":"\\bhas (?:received|attracted|drawn|generated) (?:considerable|substantial|growing|increasing|much|renewed|significant) (?:attention|interest)\\b","recency":"\\bin recent (?:years|decades)\\b|\\brecently\\b","policy_relevance":"\\bpolicy ?makers\\b|\\bpolicy (?:debates?|discussions?|interest)\\b"},"move2_niche":{"little_known":"\\blittle research\\b|\\bwe know (?:relatively |surprisingly )?little\\b|\\bless is known\\b|\\blittle is known\\b","no_few_studies":"\\bno (?:study|studies|prior study|previous study)\\b|\\b(?:very )?few (?:empirical )?(?:studies|papers)\\b","not_studied":"\\b(?:has|have) (?:not|rarely|seldom) (?:yet )?been (?:\\w+ly )?(?:studied|examined|explored|addressed|investigated|analy[sz]ed|quantified)\\b","overlooked":"\\b(?:overlooked|neglected|ignored)\\b|\\bscant attention\\b","open_question":"\\bremains? (?:unexplored|unclear|unresolved|an open question|poorly understood)\\b|\\bopen (?:question|empirical question)\\b","adversative":"\\bhowever\\b","counter_claim":"\\bcontrary to\\b|\\bchallenges? (?:the|this|these|conventional)\\b|\\b(?:conflicting|mixed|inconclusive) (?:results|findings|evidence|conclusions)\\b|\\bevidence is (?:mixed|inconclusive|scarce|limited)\\b|\\bno consensus\\b|\\b(?:ongoing|considerable) debate\\b|\\bremains? (?:controversial|contested|debated)\\b","question_raising":"\\braises? the (?:question|possibility)\\b|\\b(?:a )?natural question\\b|\\bit (?:is|remains) (?:unclear|not clear|unknown|uncertain) (?:whether|how|why|to what extent)\\b|\\ban? (?:important|interesting|open|key|central) (?:empirical )?question\\b","continuation":"\\bwe (?:build on|extend|complement|follow|depart from|contribute to|add to)\\b|\\bextends? (?:the|this|previous|prior|existing)\\b|\\b(?:closest|most closely related) to (?:our|ours|this)\\b|\\bour (?:paper|study|analysis) (?:is (?:closely )?related to|builds on|extends|complements)\\b"},"move3_occupation":{"announce":"\\bin this (?:paper|study|article),? (?:we|i)\\b|\\bthis (?:paper|study|article) (?:examines|studies|investigates|analy[sz]es|develops|provides|documents|estimates|asks|addresses|quantifies)\\b","preview_findings":"\\bwe (?:find|show|document|demonstrate)\\b|\\bwe estimate that\\b|\\bour (?:results|findings|estimates) (?:show|suggest|indicate|imply|reveal)\\b","contribution":"\\bcontribut(?:e|es|ed|ion|ions)\\b|\\bwe add to\\b","roadmap":"\\borgani[sz]ed as follows\\b|\\bproceeds as follows\\b|\\bstructured as follows\\b|\\b(?:remainder|rest) of (?:this|the) (?:paper|article)\\b"}},"conclusion":{"move1_restate":{"this_paper_has":"\\bthis (?:paper|study|article) (?:has |have )?(?:shown|examined|studied|documented|argued|estimated|analy[sz]ed|investigated|developed|provided|presented|explored)\\b","we_have":"\\bwe (?:have )(?:shown|documented|argued|found|demonstrated|estimated|examined|provided|presented|developed|studied|analy[sz]ed)\\b","in_this_paper":"\\bin this (?:paper|study|article),? (?:we|i)\\b"},"move2_implications":{"policy":"\\bpolic(?:y|ies)\\b","implications":"\\bimplications?\\b|\\bimply\\b|\\bpractical (?:relevance|importance)\\b"},"move3_limitations":{"limitation":"\\blimitations?\\b|\\bcaveats?\\b","caution":"\\b(?:interpreted|treated) with caution\\b|\\bwe cannot (?:rule out|distinguish|identify|claim)\\b|\\bbeyond the scope\\b"},"move4_future":{"future":"\\bfuture (?:research|work|studies|analysis)\\b|\\bfurther research\\b|\\bleave (?:this|these|it|them)? ?(?:questions? )?(?:for|to) future\\b|\\bfruitful avenue\\b|\\bremains? for future\\b"}},"abstract":{"move2_method":{"we_do":"\\bwe (?:use|exploit|estimate|develop|construct|study|examine|analy[sz]e|investigate|build|employ|model|evaluate|test)\\b","using_data":"\\busing (?:data|a (?:panel|sample|dataset|survey)|administrative|survey|novel|unique)\\b|\\bdata (?:from|on)\\b"},"move3_findings":{"find":"\\bwe (?:find|show|document|demonstrate)\\b|\\bwe estimate that\\b|\\b(?:results|findings|estimates) (?:show|suggest|indicate|imply|reveal)\\b"},"move4_implication":{"implication":"\\bimplications?\\b|\\b(?:results|findings) imply\\b|\\bpolicy\\b|\\bsuggest(?:s)? that (?:policy|governments?|regulators?)\\b"}}}},"section_headings":{"name":"section_headings","categories":{"abstract":"^ABSTRACT","references":"\\bREFERENCES?\\b|BIBLIOGRAPH","declarations":"FUNDING|FINANCIAL SUPPORT|CONFLICTS? OF INTEREST|ACKNOWLEDG|DECLARATION OF|CREDIT AUTHORSHIP|DATA AVAILABILITY|ETHICAL REVIEW|ETHICS (APPROVAL|STATEMENT)","introduction":"\\bINTRODUCTION\\b","literature":"LITERATURE","methods":"METHOD|ECONOMETRIC|ESTIMATION|EMPIRICAL (STRATEG|APPROACH|SPECIFICATION|ANALYSIS)|\\bEMPIRICS\\b|IDENTIFICATION|TIME SERIES MODEL","data":"\\bDATA\\b|\\bSAMPLE\\b|\\bVARIABLES\\b|DESCRIPTIVE STATISTICS|SUMMARY STATISTICS|EMPIRICAL SETTING","results":"\\bRESULTS?\\b|\\bFINDINGS\\b","discussion":"\\bDISCUSSION\\b","conclusion":"CONCLU|CONCLUDING|FINAL REMARKS|IMPLICATIONS?","model_theory":"(?<!ECONOMETRIC )(?<!EMPIRICAL )(?<!TIME SERIES )\\bMODEL(S|LING)?\\b|THEOR|CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK|THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK|EQUILIBRI","experimental_design":"EXPERIMENT(AL)? (DESIGN|SETUP|PROCEDURE|EVIDENCE)|\\bDESIGN\\b","robustness":"ROBUSTNESS|SENSITIVITY"},"priority":["references","declarations","abstract","introduction","conclusion","results","methods","data","robustness","experimental_design","model_theory","discussion","literature"]}}